I’ll state right from the start of this post, that this novel is simple, universalist heresy. It’s thought-provoking, sentimental and a little sad at times, granted, however, as a ‘read’ it’s abominable. A vast amount of Christians were wetting themselves over this book a few years ago, and now that I’ve finally gotten around to read it, a simple conclusion would be: I’ll never get those reading hours back. I was given this book by my estranged wife, who is herself, a Christian minister – she gave me the book with the best of intentions. So here’s my sort of perhaps not-so-neutral analysis, critique, call it what you like.
The Shack by William P. Young is a provocative novel that delves into themes of faith, loss, and redemption. The story follows Mackenzie ‘Mack’ Phillips, a man grappling with the abduction and presumed murder of his youngest daughter, Missy, during a family camping trip. The narrative unfolds as Mack receives a mysterious invitation to return to the shack where evidence of Missy’s murder was found, prompting him to confront his deepest pain and questions about God’s role in suffering.
One of the novel’s hiccups is its exploration of the nature of God. Through encounters with three enigmatic characters representing the Holy Trinity – Papa (God the Father), Jesus, and Sarayu (the Holy Spirit) – Mack confronts his preconceived notions about religion and gains new insights into the nature of divine love and forgiveness. The portrayal of God as a compassionate and relational figure challenges traditional depictions and encourages readers to reconsider their own beliefs – this work is attempting to persuade you away from what is sensible and right. It’s manipulative.
The novel has faced criticism for its theological implications. Some argue that the novel’s portrayal of God as a woman (Papa) and the anthropomorphisation of the Holy Trinity may blur theological lines and lead to confusion or heretical beliefs – think idolatry, the second commandment. Additionally, the book’s exploration of universalism, the idea that all people will ultimately be saved by God’s grace, has been controversial within Christian circles, as it diverges from traditional doctrines of salvation. So, we just throw hell out of the window, and sin as much as we like with no thought for the consequences, because, hey, we’re all going to Heaven in the end anyway.
Furthermore, the novel has been accused of oversimplifying complex theological concepts and relying too heavily on sentimentality to convey its message – this is true. Critics argue that the narrative’s resolution, which hinges on Mack’s emotional healing and reconciliation with God, may come across as contrived or unrealistic to some readers.
Despite these criticisms, the novel has resonated with many readers for its heartfelt exploration of grief, forgiveness, and spiritual growth. Its message of God’s unfailing love and presence in the midst of suffering has provided comfort and hope to countless individuals facing their own struggles. I suggest if you want to read this book, then you leave your emotions at the metaphorical door. Although if you’ve suffered serious loss as the protagonist has, then I apologise for seeming so harsh. I, myself, have suffered tremendous loss, and I feel emotionally manipulated by the author, who, clearly only wants to put across his own ideas at the expense of readers’ emotions. Having said that, art in whatever form is intended to make us ‘feel’, it’s supposed to draw us in so that we can experience what the artist is trying to convey. Sometimes, as in this case, it’s simply manipulation.
In conclusion, this piece of fiction is a thought-provoking novel that offers a unique perspective on faith and the human experience. While it’s been both praised and criticised for its theological implications and narrative approach, its ability to inspire introspection and foster discussions about spirituality is undeniable. Whether readers embrace its message wholeheartedly or approach it with skepticism, The Shack remains a compelling work of fiction that encourages readers to grapple with life’s deepest questions. And a work of fiction it is. A piece of work from the imagination of someone who obviously made a lot of money out of heartache and peoples’ misunderstanding or limited understanding of scripture. And yes, I’m feeling a tad cynical at the time of writing.
Sorry to be so harsh, but that’s what I think. Those are my thoughts.
Wording 